  
| Author: | randyf  | | Posted: | Jul 3, 2022 11:28 | | Subject: | Re: Please Remove Word from Minifig Titles | | Viewed: | 44 times | | Topic: | Catalog Requests | |
|
| In Catalog Requests, DeLuca writes:
| | In Catalog Requests, randyf writes:
| | In Catalog Requests, DeLuca writes:
| | In Catalog Requests, wildchicken13 writes:
| | In Catalog Requests, DeLuca writes:
| | In Catalog Requests, 1001bricks writes:
| | | | In my view, “Clone” is sufficient to ensure that
all Minifigs are listed together, and that all can be found easily by searching.
|
Please also remove "Wars" in "Star Wars"?
I mean, too bad for people searching "Trooper", don't you think so?
|
I am not sure what you are trying to say, since the comparison that you are making
is not analogous.
|
Not everyone on BrickLink is a Star Wars expert and knows the difference between the different types of clones. Is it redundant? Perhaps. But it's not really a big deal either way.
|
In my OP, I acknowledged that names like “Clone Trooper Pilot” were correct;
my issues are with their redundancy, their contribution to the inflation of already-long
names, and their awkwardness when paired with the name of a character (e.g. “Clone
Trooper Captain Rex”).
|
You do realize that you have contributed a lot to the inflation of the names on these figures, right?  So what is one more word that is easily searchable.
|
The other terms that I have added are necessary and helpful, in my view, but
you make a fair point. I can compromise on "Trooper" being included in the titles
of generic Clones Pilots and Officers (Captain, Commander, etc), but I would
prefer if we kept it out of the names of specific characters, since it reads
awkwardly to me.
BTW, why was my change to put the MagnaGuard into "Star Wars Episode 3" rejected?
My categorisation of that figure was in-line with my other recategorisations
to put designs into the categories in which they first appeared, so I am not
sure how this is different from Aayla Secura or Mace Windu. 😕
|
It was an accident and later accepted. 
|
|
Message is in Reply To: Message Has 3 Replies: 41 Messages in this Thread:  Msg 1 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 1, 2022 to Catalog Requests
 Msg 2 - 1001bricks (52464) 23 months ago Jul 2, 2022 to Catalog Requests
  Msg 3 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 4 - wildchicken13 (876) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 5 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 6 - wildchicken13 (876) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 7 - randyf (442) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 8 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 9 « - randyf (442) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 10 - 1001bricks (52464) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 11 - 1001bricks (52464) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 12 - Nubs_Select (3820)  23 months ago Jul 4, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 13 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 14 - jennnifer (3537) 23 months ago Jul 2, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 15 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 16 - jennnifer (3537) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 17 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 18 - wildchicken13 (876) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 19 - axaday (7304) 23 months ago Jul 2, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 20 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 21 - UTLF (1267) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 22 - axaday (7304) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 23 - Nubs_Select (3820) 23 months ago Jul 4, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 24 - infinibrix (5025) 23 months ago Jul 2, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 25 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 26 - UTLF (1267) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 27 - wildchicken13 (876) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 28 - UTLF (1267) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 29 - Stellar (3535) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 30 - peregrinator (782) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 31 - jennnifer (3537) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 32 - peregrinator (782) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 33 - jennnifer (3537) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 34 - yorbrick (1185) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 35 - jennnifer (3537) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 36 - tons_of_bricks (12799) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 37 - peregrinator (782) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 38 - DeLuca (288) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 39 - infinibrix (5025) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 40 - C0lsanders_ (834) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Msg 41 - yorbrick (1185) 23 months ago Jul 3, 2022 to Catalog Requests
Entire thread on one page
This message and all its replies on one page
|
USA, Ohio
