Author:  Jacob_Pf  Posted:  Oct 10, 2023 20:19  Subject:  Re: Color issue with 2546p02, Bird, Parrot with S  Viewed:  37 times  Topic:  Colors Cancel Reply

BrickLink ID Card Jacob_Pf (1) Location:  Germany, Rheinland-Pfalz Member Since Contact Type Status Oct 4, 2023 Seller Store: JJ-Bricks

In Colors, peregrinator writes:    In Colors, Jacob_Pf writes:    The red variant of https://www.bricklink.com/v2/catalog/catalogitem.page?P=2546p02#T=S&C=6&O={%22color%22:%226%22,%22iconly%22:0} does not exist. It is not part of a set and has no images. Its existence is just a result of people disagreeing whether the green or the red part of the parrot is the base color. Therefore, the red version should be removed from the catalog. The way listings work on BL is that people can list items under whatever color they want. But also, the fact that something isn't found in a set doesn't at all mean it doesn't exist. But shouldn't it be clear in this case? A red variant of this parrot would make no sense at all, its outstanding attribute is the pattern which would completely disappear and I'd be a different piece.

Message is in Reply To:

Re: Color issue with 2546p02, Bird, Parrot with S - peregrinator (782)

[...] The way listings work on BL is that people can list items under whatever color they want. But also, the fact that something isn't found in a set doesn't at all [...] (8 months ago, Oct 10, 2023, to Colors)

Message Has 2 Replies:

Re: Color issue with 2546p02, Bird, Parrot with S - Nubs_Select (3820)

as its a marbled part it can vary massively so if someones looked more green then red or vice versa some may choose to list it as such even if its technically only 1 colour (8 months ago, Oct 10, 2023, to Colors)

Re: Color issue with 2546p02, Bird, Parrot with S - peregrinator (782)

[...] I grant that this piece almost certainly doesn't exist in red. But that won't stop people from listing it. (8 months ago, Oct 10, 2023, to Colors)

19 Messages in this Thread:

 Msg 1 - Jacob_Pf (1) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 2 - peregrinator (782) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 3 « - Jacob_Pf (1) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 4 - Nubs_Select (3820) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 5 - peregrinator (782) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 6 - Jacob_Pf (1) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 7 - peregrinator (782) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 8 - Jacob_Pf (1) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 9 - jennnifer (3537) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 10 - Jacob_Pf (1) 8 months ago Oct 10, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 11 - SylvainLS (46) 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 12 - Admin_Russell 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 13 - SylvainLS (46) 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 14 - Admin_Russell 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 15 - yorbrick (1185) 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 16 - SylvainLS (46) 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 17 - Jacob_Pf (1) 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 18 - ghyde (203) 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors
 Msg 19 - yorbrick (1185) 8 months ago Oct 11, 2023 to Colors