  
| Author: | Smron  | | Posted: | Mar 15, 2017 22:41 | | Subject: | Re: Better Forum | | Viewed: | 51 times | | Topic: | Suggestions | |
|
| In Suggestions, FigBits writes:
| | In Suggestions, ranarn writes:
| | Good Question, and of course i should have stated some examples, instead of just
saying that it's bad.
First, the tree approach, it's not a bad thing, and works pretty good when
a discussion is kept relatively small and you read each post.
But when more and more people join, and you get multiple levels of replies, each
tend to go it's own way when it branches out from the main tree. And a tree
structure makes really hard for someone that is coming into the discussion later
to see the latest "talk" or get a overview what has been replied earlier, you
often need to check each branch of the tree. I am more into the "reddit" approach,
where the hot or popular replies is what is showed at the top. Or the "standard"
flat forum approach with pages and not creating branches of replies.
|
I very much disagree there, at least compared to a flat view. Having a branching
tree is a huge benefit. One improvement would be to be able to collapse a branch
(as on reddit). But if this is your major concern, I think you are way off. The
branching structure is a huge benefit of the current format. It is not a fault
at all.
| | Second is style, it looks outdated and not very modern. I know that the "CORE"
users of the forum at the moment like it, and is happy with what it is, but to
broaden the usage from new users, it needs to be made more modern and easier,
explainable icons instead of text links maybe, Simplicity is the key.
|
To me, that's largely irrelevant. I care much more about content than style.
For the site itself, the style is important, because it's a commercial website
that is looking to make money for its sellers (myself among them). But for the
forum? Who cares. The appearance is neither a positive nor a negative. It's
irrelevant.
| | Some technical features that would be nice is, notification, unread message tracking,
templates, tags, ability mention or reference other people, online status of
users, avatars etc...
|
Notifications and message tracking, absolutely. Those should be added. Tags already
exist for catalog items. Referencing other users: meh. Online status of users:
meh. Avatars? Please no. There are way too many juvenile forums where 50% of
the "content" is animated gift and signature files. That contributes nothing
to actual discussions, and we are better off without them.
So ... Yes, we could use the ability to track read/unread status, and receive
notifications.
That's about it.
--
Marc.
|
More or less agree. I'm not sure we need a 'new forum', but our current
forum could use some upgrades.
Top things I would like to see...
1) Ability to collapse threads.
2) Ability to edit posts
3) Deleting cancelled posts
4) Notifications/mentions/user tags
5) Ability to find a post 'helpful' or not. (This one isn't really
important, I just wanted to get my list to 5 things...)
|
|
Message is in Reply To:  Re: Better Forum - FigBits (3564) | [...] I very much disagree there, at least compared to a flat view. Having a branching tree is a huge benefit. One improvement would be to be able to collapse a branch (as [...]
(88 months ago, Mar 15, 2017, to Suggestions) |
Message Has 1 Reply: Re: Better Forum - Rob_and_Shelagh (26344) | [...] For me please no on that one, there is nothing worse than reading a thread that no longer makes any sense as all the replies refer to something that has been changed [...]
(88 months ago, Mar 16, 2017, to Suggestions) |
41 Messages in this Thread: Msg 1 - ranarn (271) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
 Msg 2 - StarBrick (7089) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 3 - bb844618 (66) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
  Msg 4 - ranarn (271) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 5 - randyipp (3491) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 6 - Macaronis (725) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 7 - nectara (6580) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 8 - SylvainLS (46) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 9 - viejos (670) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 10 - WoutR (922) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 11 - Cosy (613) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 12 - ranarn (271) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 13 - yorbrick (1185) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 14 - randyf (442) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 15 - viejos (670) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 16 - Rob_and_Shelagh (26344) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 17 - ranarn (271) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 18 - yorbrick (1185) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 19 - ranarn (271) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 20 - FigBits (3564) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 21 « - Smron (385) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 22 - Rob_and_Shelagh (26344) 88 months ago Mar 16, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 23 - yorbrick (1185) 88 months ago Mar 16, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 24 - ranarn (271) 88 months ago Mar 16, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 25 - Rob_and_Shelagh (26344) 88 months ago Mar 16, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 26 - viejos (670) 88 months ago Mar 16, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 27 - Rob_and_Shelagh (26344) 88 months ago Mar 16, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 28 - SylvainLS (46) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 29 - qwertyboy (7881) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 30 - Made_In_Bricks (3994) 88 months ago Mar 14, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 31 - ranarn (271) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 32 - randyf (442) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 33 - Brettj666 (1112) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 34 - Pher (2770) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 35 - Brettj666 (1112) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 36 - yorbrick (1185) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 37 - Brettj666 (1112) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 38 - Pher (2770) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 39 - yorbrick (1185) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 40 - legoman77 (3628) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Msg 41 - popsicle (6675) 88 months ago Mar 15, 2017 to Suggestions
Entire thread on one page
This message and all its replies on one page
|
Canada, Manitoba
