Author:  TorontoLego  Posted:  Dec 20, 2010 17:30  Subject:  Committee for Listing Violations  Viewed:  262 times  Topic:  Suggestions  Status: Discarded Cancel Reply

BrickLink ID Card TorontoLego (6293) Location:  Canada, Ontario Member Since Contact Type Status Sep 19, 2008 Seller Store: TORONTO BRICKS

The responses to this got me thinking: http://www.bricklink.com/message.asp?ID=498526 Would committees be a good thing for BL? I suggest a committee of 3 people for Listing violations: Have the problem reports sent to 3 members (maybe even conceal the store/user name) and let them vote. 2 votes and the listing gets removed. I'm sure we would be able to find members for a committee of 3 or maybe 5 very quickly and that decisions on listings would be decided very quickly. Obviously Admin and/or the CO would be able to appoint/remove those committee members and Admin and maybe the CO would also be able to overrule them. Mike.

Message Has 10 Replies:

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - ToriHada (8887)

[...] I voted yes Mike. But I have some tentative reservations about sellers telling other sellers what they can and cannot list for sale. This needs to be set up so that there [...] (164 months ago, Dec 20, 2010, to Suggestions)

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - therobo (9706)

Hi! Why do you think that anything should be changed in dealing with wrongly listed items? Any such listings can be reported under the problem tab and I haven't seen any posts [...] (164 months ago, Dec 20, 2010, to Suggestions)

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - InanimateReason (3464)

[...] What problem are you trying to solve here? Is it the amount of time it takes to get the currently designated person/people to respond to listing complaints? If so, why [...] (164 months ago, Dec 20, 2010, to Suggestions)

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - SimplyBricks (18738)

[...] NO, This is NOT a democratic site, all decisions made on this site are Admins only. [...] I certainly don't want or need a 'committee' to tell me how what I can list [...] (164 months ago, Dec 21, 2010, to Suggestions)

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - bagelboybugle (3408)

[...] For a position like catmins or chatmins, where there are multiple people doing the same task, there may already be an element of committee in the sense of all subject [...] (164 months ago, Dec 21, 2010, to Suggestions)

(Cancelled) - .bob (878)

(Cancelled) (164 months ago, Dec 21, 2010, to Suggestions)

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - mnementh (23252)

[...] In my experience, a committee is almost never a good thing, for anything. Troy (164 months ago, Dec 21, 2010, to Suggestions)

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - LEGOMASTER (179)

[...] I vote no. Even if it called a committee or review board, I vote no. What I worry about is 'who' would be on the 'board' and how long do they hold the position. If [...] (164 months ago, Dec 21, 2010, to Suggestions)

Re: Committee for Listing Violations - dvsntt (432)

[...] I think it is a noble suggestion but it makes me think that it should be more inclusive of everyone from those with a vested interest to those with a whimsical interest [...] (164 months ago, Dec 21, 2010, to Suggestions)

Committee for Listing Violations - AndersPaludan (822)

Yay! I like the sound of that. Like the Central Committee of the USSR and The Chinese Revolutionary Committee. :P But seriously: From a programmers point of wiew I guess it [...] (164 months ago, Dec 21, 2010, to Suggestions)

40 Messages in this Thread:

 Msg 1 « - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 2 - ToriHada (8887) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 3 - BUC (9715) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 4 - therobo (9706) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 5 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 6 - ToriHada (8887) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 7 - Speciale (4824) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 8 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 9 - Speciale (4824) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 10 - InanimateReason (3464) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 11 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 20, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 12 - SimplyBricks (18738) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 13 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 14 - ToriHada (8887) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 15 - bagelboybugle (3408) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 16 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 17 - FigBits (3562) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 18 - ToriHada (8887) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 19 - .bob (878) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 20 - mnementh (23252) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 21 - BrickBuy (40584) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 22 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 23 - mnementh (23252) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 24 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 25 - ToriHada (8887) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 26 - FigBits (3562) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 27 - Lonely_Brick_OH (10067) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 28 - BLUSER_87297 (1859) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 29 - Scrp749 (2438) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 30 - BLUSER_27495 (269) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 31 - ToriHada (8887) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 32 - tEoS (5297) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 33 - ToriHada (8887) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 34 - therobo (9706) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 35 - InanimateReason (3464) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 36 - therobo (9706) 164 months ago Dec 22, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 37 - TorontoLego (6293) 164 months ago Dec 22, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 38 - LEGOMASTER (179) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 39 - dvsntt (432) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions
 Msg 40 - AndersPaludan (822) 164 months ago Dec 21, 2010 to Suggestions